Thursday, April 18, 2024
Latest News
Arizona Republicans Splinter Over Repeal of 1864 Abortion Ban Water Supply: Water Supply Ramped Up To Meet Demand | Ahmedabad News Malabar Gold sees RS 51,000 crore annual sales Hong Kong restaurant Otera’s impressive dessert tasting experience highlights underappreciated ingredients ONE Championship: Rodtang faces Denis Puric in flyweight kickboxing bout at ONE 167 China’s autonomous driving players struggle to turn a profit despite heavy investments Trump lawyers say Stormy Daniels refused subpoena outside a Brooklyn bar, papers left 'at her feet' Food truck kingpin arrested in Stanislaus County on suspicion of theft Bhagalpur Lok Sabha Seat: Cong Goes All Out To Regain Lost Glory In Bhagalpur | Patna News Vinci Buys Majority Stake in Edinburgh Airport Met Gala 2024: Things to look forward to this year | IPL 2024: Bowlers shine as Delhi Capitals humble Gujarat Titans by six wickets | Cricket News Shock poll: Trump edges past Biden in key state, potential sign of cracks in Dems blue wall Funskool: Funskool Expands In Tamil Nadu | Chennai News China preps for tourism boom on May Day holiday as early bookings rocket past pre-pandemic levels US lawmakers target Chinese military firms helping Russia with bill imposing ‘full blocking sanctions’ Juventus ordered to pay Cristiano Ronaldo 9.7 million euros in back salary | Football News 7 Waymo robotaxis block traffic to San Francisco freeway on-ramp Missing medical colleges: On the case of the Madurai AIIMS Miscalculation Leads to Escalation as Israel and Iran Clash 2024 NFL jersey redesigns: Browns latest team to make change Bangalore News: When Bengaluru traffic dominates poll talk in Kerala | Bengaluru News Tesla asks investors to OK Musk's 56 billion dollar pay again AI roundup [April 17]: Adobe unveils Acrobat AI assistant, India eyes Nvidia GPUs for AI mission and more Air National Guard changes in Alaska could affect national security, civilian rescues, staffers say Biden says uncle shot down over area populated by cannibals in World War Two Muzaffar Ali and Meera Ali on World Heritage Day: Delhi is Delhi because of its monuments | Delhi News Just Eat Orders Drop But Keeps Outlook Gujarat businessman and wife donate property worth Rs 200 crore to become Jain monks | US strategy for Indo-Pacific region must promote economic development, not just defence: Senate panel
HomeOpinionsElection as referendum: The Hindu Editorial on Scotland’s independence

Election as referendum: The Hindu Editorial on Scotland’s independence


The United Kingdom’s Supreme Court ruling has extinguished, at least for the moment, the hopes of the Scottish National Party to conduct later next year a “consultative plebiscite” — a non-binding referendum on whether Scotland should be an independent nation. The highest court squashed two claims made by the Scottish government: first, that the consultative aspect of the referendum implied that it would have no constitutional consequences and fell entirely within the legal scope of devolved powers, and second, that it carried legitimacy under international law, which permits democratic expressions of the right to national self-determination. The court argued that the devolved Parliament in Holyrood did not essentially have the power to authorise a second referendum on independence — the first being in 2014 — unless the Westminster Parliament agreed it could do so — which, unsurprisingly, in the climate of political uncertainty, it has not blessed. Further, the U.K. Supreme Court has posited, the SNP’s draft bill for the referendum would likely have constitutional ramifications. Second, the court found that Scotland’s position vis-à-vis the U.K. was not comparable to the scenario of a sub-national region occupied by a malign foreign power, subject to exploitative colonial control and refused the right to democratic representation of collective will. Given that this basic standard for making claims to independence under international law could not be met, in the eyes of the top court, it was not possible now for such deliberations to reach beyond the borders.

One thing is clear: SNP leader and First Minister of Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, “is not an extremist”. While recognising that the Scottish government will have to abide by the court’s ruling, she has however said that she wants the next U.K. general election to be a “de facto referendum” on independence, based on the plan for the SNP to make it a single-issue campaign, not dramatically different from the U.K.’s Conservative Party interpreting several elections as referendums on Brexit. There are two related issues with this framing. First, the political space for Scottish voters to express their preferences on issues other than whether Scotland ought to be independent would have disappeared, and that is not good for substantive democracy. Second, if the SNP is using the independence referendum issue to divert attention from its performance in government as an incumbent (administration of public services including the NHS and the regional economy), then that too does not help the cause of good governance in Scotland. Westminster would be wise to do more to win over Scottish hearts and minds, instead of relying on the harder route of judicial and political vetoes on referendums.



Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Latest News